See all photos
Peyton Wallace

4 Cottle Lane

$4,195,000 4 Cottle Lane, Edgartown, MA 02539
Stunning gut-renovated historic home in the heart of downtown Edgartown! Completely re-imagined to meet modern tastes and comforts, this beautiful brand new home provides welcome respite from the hustle and bustle. With views of the Dr. Daniel Fisher house and gardens, this property has so many rare elements. Architecturally balanced and blended between old and new by Sasha Robinson-White, the residence was rebuilt from top to bottom to an exceptionally high level. The exterior, which includes much of the original ca. 1862 structure, strikes all the right notes for downtown Edgartown, and now includes all new windows, brand new roof and clapboard siding, and over 3,000 square feet of decks on two levels. The interior features traditional elements like a jaw-dropping coffered great room, knotty whitewashed oak floors, a front parlor, butler’s pantry and more. The home also incorporates modern aspects where desired, exemplified by a state of the art kitchen with extensive cabinetry, Wolf and Sub-Zero appliances, and quartz countertops. All four and one half bathrooms offer spa-like experiences, featuring the finest choices in tile and fixtures. Five bedrooms are spread through both levels of the house, with a large den and office providing bonus living areas. Overall, the home is exceptionally bright, airy, and inviting - just the perfect option for in-town living. The oversize lot offers plenty of room to spread out to ample lawn or garden areas.
  • Sold
  • 5
  • 4.5
  • 1862
    Year Built
  • 4,265 Sq.Ft.
    Living Area

Features & Amenities

Area & Lot

  • Status: Sold
  • Living Space: 4,265 Sq.Ft.
  • Lot Size: 0.23 Acres
  • MLS® ID: 37935
  • Year Built: 1862
  • View Description: None, Twn


  • Total Bedrooms: 5
  • Total Bathrooms: 4.5
  • Full Bathrooms: 4
  • Half Bathrooms: 1
  • Flooring: Oak/Tile
  • Fireplace: 1
  • Appliances: Stove: Wolf, Washer: Y
  • Other Interior Features: AC, Ins, Floor 1: Dramatic open living spaces Beautiful great room with living/dining areas, wood burning fireplace, coffered ceiling Expansive brand new kitchen with custom cabintery, center island, quartz counters, butler s pantry and more One bedroom, one full bathroom, one half bathroom, den, and office areas, Floor 2: 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms and laundry room The master includes walk-in closet, luxurious bathroom, private deck and views over lawns of the neighboring Daniel Fisher House property

Exterior & Building

  • Water Source: Town
  • Utilities: Cbl
  • Lot Features: Spacious back yard
  • Parking: Brick parking area
  • Heat Type: GFHA
  • Sewer: Twn
  • Substructure: Irregular
  • Other Exterior Features: Pub Bch, Deck


  • Sales Price: $4,195,000
  • Real Estate Tax: $6,231/yr
  • Zoning: R5

4 Cottle Lane

Work With Us

From representing sellers through a comprehensive marketing plan to representing buyers with an educated view of the current market, Peyton & Bill strive to provide the highest quality service and go beyond the expected.
Contact Us
Follow Us