Read what our clients have to say.


Peyton was responsive, patient and an excellent negotiator in a competitive real estate climate. Highly recommend him to anyone navigating a home purchase on Martha's Vineyard!


Peyton is extremely knowledgeable and professional. He helped me find the perfect house on Martha's Vineyard. I would highly recommend him for anyone looking for a property on-island!


Attentive to your needs and able to put the deal together to satisfaction of all. he was the Realtor® for 95 Hammett Lane in Chilmark , MA. He helped put the deal together in a way that worked financially.

John Cohara

Wonderful attention to detail from start thru finish. Great listening skills. Really knows the island and is an expert in assessing value. Could not have purchased our little Vineyard cottage without his sage advice!


Peyton Wallace was very helpful to me with my purchase of a home on Marthas Vinyard. His knowledge and skill in regards to property on the island was exceptional, and I would highly recommend Peyton to anybody looking to purchase a home!

Hollis McLaughlin

Peyton did an excellent job helping us find a home on the island. We looked at every possible house in our price range and it took us a very long time. But Peyton was ready to show us anything we wanted to see. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for a home.

Heidi Ryder

Peyton helped us to purchase a new property on MV and to sell our existing home there. Highly knowledgeable and responsive to any and all asks from both sides. The sales on both ends went smoothly from start to finish with continued good guidance from Peyton on next steps.

Barbara Ann Petersen

Peyton was referred to us by a trusted source as a local expert who could help us understand the real estate market on Martha's Vineyard. We could not have been happier with his service, from his initial responsiveness through and beyond our negotiations and purchase. I recommend him highly!

Carl Erdman

Very responsive from the beginning to the end of the process. Very good negotiator while clearly looking out for our interests. He was always ready to walk from the deal if necessary. Very helpful with recommendations of service providers both before and after closing. Knows the market. Can’t say enough about Peyton.


Peyton was the most patient, knowledgeable, and skilled Realtor® that we have ever partnered with (in 35 years of home purchasing and about 10 homes). He helped us narrow our search to the areas and types of properties that best suited us, despite our varied tastes, and then spent countless days helping us look. We were most impressed!

Work With Us

From representing sellers through a comprehensive marketing plan to representing buyers with an educated view of the current market, Peyton & Bill strive to provide the highest quality service and go beyond the expected.
Contact Us
Follow Us